External reviews from AniList users — not Anime Guider reviews.
Gosick: A Romance Anime that is the Pinnacle of Historical Fiction Anime
As a kid I spent a lot of time reading Sherlock Holmes. I am a HUGE fan of mystery in general. I am also a huge fan of romance, drama, history and everything foreign. So taking this all into account, this anime immediately caught my attention. This anime takes place in an alternate universe, but I b…
Read full review on AniList →Half decent first cour, falls apart into a mess in the second. Not much of a romance or mystery honestly.
# __Just a warning, this review will contain some SPOILERS for the show. Warnings have been had__.
So you have 24 episodes to adapt 9 volumes of light novel to a well rounded and enjoyable anime, sounds like a great plan. You have plenty of time to build up your characters and story and lead u…
Read full review on AniList →My little Sherlock Holmes can't be this cute
Set in the early 1900s, Gosick tells a grand tale of war and betrayal alongside love presented as a beautifully written spectacle that unfolds over a mere 24 episodes. Initially, I hesitated to watch it as historical and mystery anime are usually not my preference. However, from the get-go, I was pu…
Read full review on AniList →Fixing our daddy issues through master/servant play
Kujo’s a simp, Victorica needs cps, Cordelia needs more screen time, and Grevil can kiss my ***. Language ahead.
May I first start by saying that Gosick is not bad.
However, Gosick does suffer from is these “discrepancies,” which is the best term I can think of, where **** just kinda doesn’t real…
Read full review on AniList →An anime with issues but also a great example of character development and an improvement of the story near it's final.
~~~I don't know if I ever experienced and had a development process, like the one I had with Gosick. With the last third of episodes, my impression and view on this anime changed completely. This already implicates that I absolutely disliked the first two thirds of the total episodes.
First we star…
Read full review on AniList →Tinha gostado bastante dele, mas só foi decaindo a cada episódio

Faz anos que eu vejo em vários sites e recomendações de um monte de pessoa, mas por algum motivo esperei até agora para assistir. Só porque tem a Sawashiro miyuki, infelizmente ela faz uma personagem que mal aparece e quando aparece mal fala.
O anime é sobre um…
Read full review on AniList →